Hailstones resting on asphalt roof shingles after a storm, a factor behind homeowners insurance premiums

Why Homeowners Insurance Premiums Keep Rising

U.S. home insurance rates rose a cumulative 46.8 percent from 2020 to 2025, and no state escaped an increase.

The reasons are mostly mechanical: what it costs to rebuild a house, what storms cost insurers, and what insurers pay to insure themselves.

How Far Homeowners Insurance Premiums Have Climbed Since 2020

LendingTree’s 2026 State of Home Insurance report, as covered by Insurance Journal, put the national increase at 46.8 percent over five years. The yearly pace accelerated after 2022, peaked at 12.7 percent in 2024 and eased slightly in 2025. Colorado had the largest cumulative increase at 100.8 percent.

Insurify’s 2026 projections frame the same trend against inflation. Since 2021 the average cost of home insurance has risen 46 percent while inflation over that period was 16 percent. Insurify counts 2026 as the fifth consecutive year of rising premiums.

The Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies gives the longer view: from the Great Recession through 2024, homeowners insurance prices rose 74 percent while home prices rose more than 40 percent, even after adjusting for inflation.

Location sets the starting point. LendingTree’s 2026 data put the national average at $2,395 a year. Oklahoma had the highest average at $5,298 and Hawaii the lowest at $801, a gap that follows exposure to hail, tornadoes, hurricanes and wildfire. In 2025 Insurify recorded increases of 34 percent in Minnesota, 33 percent in Colorado and 28 percent in Iowa, and found that premiums in the 25 most expensive states rose 14 percent against 5 percent in the 25 cheapest.

Why Rebuilding Costs and Storm Losses Keep Pushing Rates Up

Home insurance premiums are tied in large part to the cost of rebuilding a home, Insurify explains, and a policy is therefore priced against today’s construction costs and not the purchase price. When materials and labor cost more, the dwelling limit rises and the premium follows even if the roof, the walls and the claims history stay exactly as they were.

Weather losses add a second layer. Insurify reports that severe convective storms, the tornado, hail and straight-line wind events common in the Midwest and Great Plains, caused more than $52 billion in insured losses in 2025, the third-highest total on record. In at least four states, insurers paid out more in claims than they collected in premiums in 2024.

A Treasury Department analysis of more than 246 million homeowners policies from 2018 to 2022 points the same way. The Federal Insurance Office found that homeowners in communities hit by substantial weather events pay far more than those elsewhere.

Insurers also buy their own protection. Aon’s catastrophe analysis, as summarized by Insurance Business, notes that reinsurance contracts carry high attachment points that leave primary insurers exposed to frequent storm losses. When that protection gets pricier, insurers can pass some of the cost into premiums, even in a ZIP code that had a calm year.

Rate changes do not always wait for renewal, and what can trigger a mid-policy rate change has its own answers.

A Hypothetical Colorado Couple, 2020 to 2025

Consider a hypothetical Colorado couple who paid $1,640 a year in 2020. This is an illustration, not a real household, and it assumes their premium moved exactly with the state’s 100.8 percent cumulative increase. The 2025 premium would be $3,293, an increase of $1,653 a year, or $138 a month.

A fixed-rate mortgage payment stays flat for the life of the loan while the insurance line grows into a larger share of the housing budget each year.

The Zebra’s 2026 survey of first-time buyers shows how that pressure registers: 74 percent said insurance is a significant part of their housing budget, and 47 percent said they would struggle to afford their mortgage if premiums rose further.

Car insurance works on a similar cycle, and how renewal timing moves the price explains it for auto policies.

How Escrow Turns a Premium Increase Into a Higher Payment

Most homeowners with a mortgage never write the insurance check themselves. The lender collects one-twelfth of the premium with each payment and pays the insurer when the policy renews, and that is how an increase reaches the household through the mortgage statement.

Servicers review the account once a year. If insurance or property tax bills come in higher than what was collected, the account runs short, and PennyMac’s escrow FAQ describes the usual outcome: the shortage is divided by 12 and added to the new monthly payment unless the borrower pays it in full.

The annual escrow statement is the place to look. It separates what changed in the insurance line from what changed in property taxes, and only the insurance line responds to the quotes and coverage choices covered in the next section.

Practical Steps for Homeowners With a Rising Premium

Start with quotes a few weeks before the renewal date, and ask each insurer to price the dwelling limit and deductible you carry today. Raise the deductible only to an amount you hold in cash, because a higher deductible lowers the premium and the saving disappears if a claim forces you to borrow the difference.

Check the dwelling limit against current rebuilding costs. A limit set years ago can fall short of what a rebuild costs now, and that gap is one no premium saving covers.

Keep a renewal log. Write down the premium, the dwelling limit and the deductible every year, and the log shows which of the three moved when the bill did.

To test what a home costs in year ten, model insurance at a higher figure than today’s and add the line for how property tax increases raise housing payments, since escrow often carries both.

What to Carry Into Next Year’s Renewal

The premium is the housing cost that resets on a schedule the homeowner does not control. The parts within reach are the coverage chosen and the date quotes get collected.

FAQ

Why do reports give different average premiums?
Each report counts something different. LendingTree builds its figures from rates in insurer filings, while Insurify updated its methodology in 2026 to reflect dwelling coverage values and peril-specific deductibles, which makes $2,395 and $2,948 different measurements.

Is home insurance still rising in 2026?
Insurify projects a 4 percent increase to an average of $3,057 by the end of 2026. LendingTree’s data show the pace easing to 6.0 percent in 2025 after its 2024 peak, and premiums are still rising, only more slowly.

What is a dwelling limit?
The dwelling limit is the most a policy pays to repair or rebuild the structure of the home itself. Personal belongings, liability and temporary living costs sit under separate limits on the same policy, so raising one does not raise the others.

Should I get an insurance quote before making an offer on a home?
Yes. The Zebra’s survey found first-time buyers expected to pay $2,692 a year on average and ended up paying $2,887, a gap a quote can close before the offer.

About the Author
Wealth Power is edited by Dilip Kumar Bharati. Articles on U.S. personal finance are researched and drafted with AI assistance using public sources such as IRS data, Bureau of Labor Statistics reports and Federal Reserve publications, and are reviewed and edited by him before publication.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Individual financial situations vary. Readers should consult a qualified financial, tax, or legal professional before making any financial decisions.